COMPARATIVE STUDY OF USING FLEXIBLE AND RIGID PAVEMENTS FOR ROADS: A REVIEW STUDY

  • SHAAFAN ABDULLAH TAHER
  • SHEYAN ALYOUSIFY
  • HUSSEIN JALAL ASWAD HASSAN
Keywords: Rigid pavement; Flexible pavement; Pavement types; Concrete road; Asphalt road; Life cycle cost

Abstract

Roads have become an essential measure and symbol of the development of societies. Road
construction projects are essential infrastructure facilities for any countries, and high amounts of the
budget allocated every financial year by decision-maker. The construction of road required researches,
good plan and design, and excellent builders to discover innovatively and cost-effective engineered
products to satisfy the increasing request that would economize the construction as well as increasing
durability. Despite the economic factor, this study will present a comparative review on the suitability of
using rigid and flexible pavements in road depending on traffic, climate, foundation, life cost, materials,
maintainability and safety consideration. The reviewed studies show that the design of concrete pavement
is based on flexural strength whereas in the asphalt pavement is based on load distributing characteristics
of the component layers. The concrete pavement life is slightly longer than asphalt pavement. The initial
cost of the flexible pavement less than the cost of rigid pavement but conversely, the cost of flexible
pavement is more than the rigid pavement with the long run because of the incurring costs of maintenance.
The rigid pavement has better ability and durability to hold a shape against traffic and difficult
environmental conditions than flexible pavement.

Downloads

Download data is not yet available.

References

AASHTO (1993). Guide for Design of Pavement
Structures, Transportation Research Board,
National Research Council, Washington, DC.
Ahammed, M. A. (2009). Safe, quiet and durable
pavement surfaces. Doctoral dissertation,
University of Waterloo, Canada.
Ahammed, M. A., and Tighe, S. L. (2009). Early-life,
long-term, and seasonal variations in skid
resistance in flexible and rigid pavements.
Transportation research record, 2094(1),
112-120.
Alliance, A. P. (2010). Pavement type selection.
IM-45. Asphalt Pavement Alliance. Lanham,
MD.
American Concrete Pavement Association (ACPA)
(2007). Green Highways Environmentally and
Economically Sustainable Concrete
Pavements. Concrete pavement research and
technology special report, (3), 10-20.
Bansal, P. (2018). Evaluation of Design and Cost
Aspects of Flexible and Rigid Pavements.
Berechman, J. (2003). Transportation––economic
aspects of Roman highway development: the
case of Via Appia. Transportation Research
Part A: Policy and Practice, 37(5), 453-478.
Bezabih, A. G., and Chandra, S. (2009). Comparative
study of flexible and rigid pavements for
different soil and traffic conditions. In Journal
of the Indian Roads Congress (pp. 153-162).
Gadja, J. W., & VanGeem, M. G. (2001). A
comparison of six environmental impacts of
Portland cement concrete and asphalt cement
concrete pavements. PCA R&D Serial, (2068),
USA: Portland Cement Association.
Ghanizadeh, A. R. (2016). An optimization model for
design of asphalt pavements based on IHAP
code number 234. Advances in Civil
Engineering, 2016.
Grzyl, B., Kristowski, A., Jamroz, K., and Gobis, A.
(2017). Methods of estimating the cost of
traffic safety equipment’s life cycle. In
MATEC Web of Conferences (Vol. 122, p.
02003). EDP Sciences.
Hayat, A., Khan, M. J., and Naeem, M. M. (2019).
Study of Failure in Rigid Pavements: A
Review. International journal of
multidisciplinary sciences and engineering,
vol. 10, no. 2.
Jain, S., Joshi, Y. P., and Goliya, S. S. (2013). Design
of rigid and flexible pavements by various
methods and their cost analysis of each
method. International Journal of Engineering
Research and Applications, 3(5), 119-123.
Kazda, A., and Caves, R. E. (2007). Airport design
and operation. Amsterdam: Elsevier.
Ketema, Y., Quezon, E. T., and Kebede, G. (2016).
Cost and Benefit Analysis of Rigid and
Flexible Pavement: A Case Study at Chancho–
Derba-Becho Road Project. International
Journal of Scientific and Engineering
Research, 7(10), 181-188.
Kristowski, A., Grzyl, B., Kurpińska, M., and Pszczoł,
M. (2018). The rigid and flexible road
pavements in terms of life cycle costs.
Kumar, A. (2017). A Study of Design and Methods of
Rigid and Flexible Highway Pavements.
Medani, T. O., Ziedan, A. S., and Hussein, A. G.
(2016). Initial Cost Comparison of Rigid and
Flexible Pavements Case Study: Khartoum
State. University Of Khartoum Engineering
Journal, 4(2).
Missouri Department of Transportation (MoDOT)
(2004). Pavement Design and Type Selection
Process. Jefferson City, Missouri.
Mohod V. Milind and Kadam N. K. (2016). A Comparative Study on Rigid and Flexible
Pavement: A Review. IOSR Journal of
Mechanical and Civil Engineering, (13),
84-88.
Otti, V. I., Nwolun, C., and Ezechukwu, M. D. K.
(2016). Rigid pavement as an alternative to
flexible pavement failure in ogbaru swampy
area. Civil and environmental research (IISTE),
8(3), 2225-0514.
Scheving, A. G. (2011). Life Cycle Cost Analysis of
Asphalt and Concrete Pavements. Doctoral
dissertation, Reykjavík University, Iceland.
Skrzypczak, I., Radwański, W., & Pytlowany, T.
(2018). Durability vs technical-the usage
properties of road pavements. In E3S Web of
Conferences (Vol. 45, p. 00082). EDP
Sciences.
Soedirdjo, T. L., Hendarto, S., and Triadi, A. (2003).
Evaluation of traffic noise in arterial road with
different road roughness. In Proc. Eastern
Asia Soc. Transportat. Studies (Vol. 4, pp.
1376-1389).
Suryakanta (2015). 2 most common types of
pavements [flexible and rigid]. Available at:
https://civilblog.org/2015/09/09/2-most-comm
on-types-of-pavements-flexible-and-rigid/.
Szostak, R. (1991). Role of Transportation in the
Industrial Revolution: A Comparison of
England and France. McGill-Queen's
Press-MQUP.
Taha, E. A. M., Yousef, K. A., and Ibrahim, O. Y. A.
(2017). Comparative Design of Rigid and
Flexible Pavement (Doctoral dissertation,
Sudan University of Science and Technology).
Tare, V., and Chaurasia, P. (2018). Development of
EDC software for economic analysis of
pavements. Development, 5(03).
Transportation Systems Center (TSC) (2013).
Inspector’s Manual for Hot-Mixed Asphalt and
Portland Cement Concrete Pavement
Construction. New York: Taylor and Francis.
Ukar, S., Akakin, T., and Engin, Y. (2007). Cost
Comparison of Rigid and Flexible Pavements:
Applications in Turkey. In ERMCO, Seville
Congress.
Villacres, J. N. (2005). Pavement Life-Cycle Cost
Studies Using Actual Cost Data–A Synthesis.
Asphalt Pavement Alliance Report, Maryland,
USA.
Wimsatt, A. J., Chang-Albitres, C. M., Krugler, P. E.,
Scullion, T., Freeman, T. J., and Valdovinos, M.
B. (2009). Considerations for rigid vs. flexible
pavement designs when allowed as alternate
bids: technical report (No.
FHWA/TX-09/0-6085-1). Texas
Transportation Institute.
Yazdani, G. (2018). Effect of Nanopolymer Modified
Binder on Hot Mix Asphalt. Thesis, University
of North Dakota, USA.
Published
2021-01-02
How to Cite
TAHER, S. A., ALYOUSIFY, S., & HASSAN, H. J. A. (2021). COMPARATIVE STUDY OF USING FLEXIBLE AND RIGID PAVEMENTS FOR ROADS: A REVIEW STUDY. Journal of Duhok University, 23(2), 222-234. Retrieved from https://journal.uod.ac/index.php/uodjournal/article/view/926